Tubular Boxification – Tube It In 2

If you’ve been involved in the puzzle community for a long time, you have certainly heard of the puzzle Tube It In designed by Wil Strijbos.  The original version was made by Wil using square metal tubes.  It was later made by Cubicdissection using a variety of exotic woods for each of the 14 pieces.  It was so popular that Cubicdissection put out a release every few years for a total of 6 releases, starting with a small release made by John Devost in 2006.

Fast forward to today where William Hu has revisited and tweaked the design to make it more challenging.  William 2 extended the difficulty by trading compactness for complexity.  It also trades more expensive exotic woods for more affordable 3D printed plastic although I wouldn’t be surprised to see an exotic wood version show up in the near future.

It’s been a decade since I acquired a very nice exotic wood version of Tube It In from Cubicdissection (Totally Tubular Dude! - Tube It In).  My sketchy recollection is that the solve was straightforward and on the easy side.  However, recent feedback that I’ve seen on Tube It In 2 has indicated that the new version is more of a challenge.  And so I decided to 3D print a copy and give it a try.  The one change I made was to turn the 2 outer tubes into a box.  Less aesthetic but more practical.  It doesn’t change the solve.

The objective of Tube It In 2 is the same as the original – pack the tubes so that they are all nestled within the largest tube.  After an hour, I hardily agreed with the comments that this version was much tougher than the original.  It doesn’t take long to realize that there are many ways to pack all the pieces except 1.  In fact you can pack them all except for the smallest piece without too much effort.  Some of those almost-packings are trivial and others are more involved.  The thing that they have in common is the inability to add that last piece.

One of the things that makes this version so much harder is the large amount of unused empty space.  It’s a real challenge corralling those empty bits together to accept another piece.  Of course to get from the trivial packings to the more advanced ones, it seems that you have to waste more space.  But take heart in knowing that there is a lot of unused space when it’s solved.

Needless to say, I spent a lot of time revisiting the same potential configurations over and over again until I finally saw the light at the end of the tube.  This is a significant update to the original Tube It In and I would recommend getting a copy.  Especially if it becomes available in a variety of exotic woods.